Fireside Chats with ChatGPT: Are FOIA requests still coming back heavily redacted?

Please see related FOIA Warnings here:

FOIA Request For US Adoptees

+

I recently asked ChatGPT:

Are FOIA requests still coming back heavily redacted?

ChatGPT said:

+

“FOIA and redactions:

Yes. As of November 2026, FOIA requests in the United States are still frequently coming back with significant redactions, and in some agencies, heavily redacted or partially withheld records remain the norm rather than the exception.

However, there is an important distinction: FOIA has not stopped working, and agencies do release substantial amounts of information. The problem is that the information released can be heavily blacked out, partially withheld, or withheld entirely under statutory exemptions.

The latest federal statistics and reporting support that conclusion.

1. The latest government-wide statistics

The Department of Justice published its FY2025 government-wide FOIA summary on July 2, 2026.

Among the 1,635,055 requests processed during FY2025:

Outcome

Percentage

Partial grant / partial denial

37.74%

Full grant

9.54%

Full denial based on exemptions

3.17%

No records found

29.73%

The most important figure is that 37.74% resulted in partial disclosure and partial withholding.

That means more than one in three requests that were processed resulted in some information being withheld under FOIA.

Source URLs:

2. Some agencies are considerably worse than others

A particularly revealing example is the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).

According to FY2025 statistics discussed in a September 2026 Washington Post investigation:

  • Only 2.3% of DHS requests resulted in records being released without redactions.

  • Approximately 40% resulted in records being released with redactions.

  • Other requests resulted in full denials, no records being found, or other dispositions.

This is a striking indication of how difficult it can be to obtain completely unredacted government records.

Source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/2026/09/26/government-is-enlisting-ai-help-decide-what-public-records-you-get-see/

3. Is the government actually becoming more aggressive about redactions?

There is another significant development.

In September 2026, reporting revealed that federal agencies are increasingly exploring artificial intelligence to identify and recommend FOIA redactions.

Examples include:

  • Customs and Border Protection using Google's AI and machine-learning tools.

  • The Interior Department using Microsoft technology to identify potentially privileged attorney-client material.

  • The Justice Department using AI technology for video redaction.

  • The Department of Health and Human Services developing additional automated redaction capabilities.

The stated objective is to speed up FOIA processing.

However, transparency advocates have raised concerns that automated systems could make excessive withholding easier.

Source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/2026/09/26/government-is-enlisting-ai-help-decide-what-public-records-you-get-see/

4. Are there legal limits on how much agencies can redact?

Yes. This is important.

Under the FOIA Improvement Act of 2016, agencies generally cannot withhold information unless they reasonably foresee that disclosure would harm an interest protected by a FOIA exemption, or disclosure is prohibited by law.

Some commonly invoked exemptions include:

  • Exemption 3: Information protected by other federal statutes.

  • Exemption 4: Confidential commercial or financial information.

  • Exemption 5: Certain privileged government communications.

  • Exemption 6: Personal privacy.

  • Exemption 7: Certain law-enforcement records.

Agencies are also generally required to release reasonably segregable portions of records that are not exempt.

The law: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2023-title5/pdf/USCODE-2023-title5-partI-chap5-subchapII-sec552.pdf 

5. My overall assessment

I would characterize the current situation this way:

Question

Assessment

Are FOIA redactions still common?

Yes

Are partial releases common?

Yes

Are completely unredacted releases common?

No, particularly at some agencies

Are agencies still withholding entire documents?

Yes

Is AI potentially increasing redaction concerns?

Yes

Can requesters challenge excessive redactions?

Yes

One particularly important point: A partial FOIA release does not automatically mean the redactions are legally justified. Agencies sometimes reconsider their withholding decisions after administrative appeals or litigation.

For example, a 2025 case documented an agency initially redacting virtually all responsive records before reversing some of those decisions following litigation-related challenges.

Source: https://www.justice.gov/oip/us-right-know-v-dod-no-23-02956-2025-wl-860503-nd-cal-mar-19-2025-hixson-mag-j 

Bottom line

Yes, significant FOIA redactions remain a substantial problem in 2026. The latest statistics show that partial disclosures are extremely common, and DHS provides a particularly striking example of how rarely agencies release records completely unredacted.

One important qualification: Government-wide statistics measure partial disclosures, not the percentage of individual pages or words blacked out. So we cannot conclude that every partially granted request is heavily redacted.

If you're asking because you're considering submitting FOIA requests yourself, I would also pay particular attention to how to challenge excessive redactions, rather than simply accepting an agency's initial determination. That is an area where requesters can sometimes obtain considerably more information.”

+

Please see related FOIA Warnings here:

FOIA Request For US Adoptees

Previous
Previous

The Blue House’s official release: “November 11 (Wed.): Overseas Korean Policy Task Force Holds First Subcommittee Meeting on Overseas Korean Adoptees”

Next
Next

Is NCRC withholding KSS Adoptees’ FILE Numbers?