Why the discovery of KSS Books could NOT have led to the decoding of KSS K-Numbers.

Image source: Online archive.

Why the discovery of KSS Books could NOT have led to the decoding of KSS K-Numbers.

+

Dr. Philsik Shin (an adoption researcher in S. Korea) shared with me on December 21st, 2022 during a Zoom about a recent discovery by a friend of his of a pair of KSS books. Dr. Shin’s friend had shared widely about the discovery to various KSS Adoptees, which is how I came to learn about it. I then asked Dr. Shin for further information.

In what back then I immediately perceived as a (first) sign of deception, I was NEVER told directly of this discovery of KSS books by Dr. Shin’s friend himself — despite the fact that I had confidentially informed Dr. Shin’s friend of my decoding of KSS K-Numbers between 2020-2021 during a Zoom in February 2022. Due to absolutely NO fault or knowledge of Dr. Shin, Dr. Shin’s friend would later be FALSELY credited with my KSS K-Number research by DKRG on January 1st, 2023. It would take Dr. Shin’s friend over one year to finally admit he had NO role in decoding KSS K-Numbers.

The actions of DKRG and of Dr. Shin’s friend in relation to attempted plagiarism of my KSS K-Number research (amongst other transgressions by DKRG) have tragically resulted in the likely PERMANENT LOSS of another set of important KSS books, which I saw at KSS in 2019 — KSS’ Death Books.

It should be noted that this discovery of these other KSS books (NOT the KSS death books) by Dr. Shin’s friend sometime in late 2022 was made AFTER I had already unfortunately informed Dr. Shin’s friend of my KSS K-Number decoding in February 2022, after being introduced with good intentions by Dr. Shin, who knew of our mutual interest in KSS. It was the worst decision I have ever made in my life to agree to connect with and confide in this Non-Adoptee DoKAD friend of Dr. Shin’s, who is the son of two KSS Adoptees — both of whom privately admitted to witnessing my conducting my KSS K-Number research — while also pressuring me to allow their son to keep the false credit later ascribed to him for my work.

Due to the fact that Dr. Shin and his friend were NOT allowed to photograph the pages of individual Adoptees, and the fact that these books do NOT cover ALL of KSS’ years of operation, there is absolutely NO WAY that KSS K-Numbers could have been decoded from Dr. Shin and his friend’s restricted viewing of these books in 2022, access to which was strictly controlled by a curator.

However, Dr. Shin’s friend has tried to make the case that he decoded KSS K-Numbers directly from these KSS books.

But there are several reasons why decoding KSS K-Numbers from these KSS books would have been IMPOSSIBLE. Apart from the obvious reasons I will describe below, there are also unobvious reasons which I will not publicly describe.

Based on what Dr. Shin told me about the discovery of these KSS books almost immediately after they were found — the fact that access to them was extremely restricted, and the fact that they only cover the years 1964 through 1983 (while KSS remained open until 2012) — there is absolutely NO WAY that all KSS K-Number codes could have been decoded through such severely restricted access to these books, which do NOT cover ALL of KSS’ history.

And there are NO photographs to prove that Dr. Shin and his friend even SAW ALL of the pages of the book — there is only photographic evidence of two pages on which the K-Numbers of Dr. Shin’s friend’s KSS Adoptee parents are listed (from 1973 and 1975), and purportedly a few pages of statistics. There is therefore NOTHING to PROVE that any kind of KSS K-Number decoding took place by the restricted viewing of these KSS books in 2022.

By contrast, my KSS K-Number research has been validated in the press on three separate occasions, between 2022-2026. I have film evidence of my visit to KSS in 2021 in which I used my knowledge of KSS’ K-Number codes to try to identify my real file, which is included in the 2022 SBS documentary about my case. This was witnessed directly by an Associated Press (AP) reporter who was present at my 2021 meeting at KSS. During this meeting, KSS’ Director CONFIRMED these codes to me and confirmed my finding that KSS K-Numbers REPEATED in the 1970s, on camera.

I had already decoded KSS K-Numbers by 2021, and had already (unfortunately) confidentially informed Dr. Shin’s friend of these codes in February 2022 — BEFORE the KSS books were found later that year. So it is completely unfounded for anyone to claim that KSS K-Number decoding occurred as a result of looking at these KSS books, given that access to them was severely restricted by a curator, and that photographs of the books’ pages were extremely limited.

Additionally, there would have been NO WAY to determine certain hidden caveats about KSS’ K-Number encoding (which I had already determined by 2021) simply by looking at these books.

WISHING that one had made an original discovery such as mine — that KSS encoded its K-Numbers in the first digit for the Partner Western Adoption Agencies — is NOT THE SAME as ACTUALLY DOING IT.

At least I have a sense of ethics, and don’t try to take false credit for the discovery of these KSS books myself…

My knowledge of all of this may come as a surprise to Dr. Shin’s DoKAD friend…since I have never shared publicly before that I have been aware of the discovery of these KSS books for years.

However, I have also known for years that decoding KSS’ K-Numbers from these books would have been impossible.

+

According to my notes from my Zoom with Dr. Shin on December 21st, 2022, Dr. Shin told me:

“That KSS book looked so precious. The book contained all KSS overseas adoptees' Korean names from 1965 to 1983 and annual KSS overseas adoption statistics from 1965 to 1983. But it was impossible to take pictures of the pages listing the adoptees' names, so (we) asked permission to take pictures of the annual statistics pages, and we were allowed to photograph those pages.”

In other words — the curator did NOT allow individual pages listing Adoptees’ information — including their K-Numbers — to be photographed except for pages related to two specific Dutch KSS Adoptees from the 1970s and a few pages of statistics. There is thus NO PROOF that KSS K-Numbers were decoded from this book.

Based on my research, ALL Dutch KSS Adoptees have the first digit KSS K-Number code “3”. However, in order to confirm this from the KSS books, Dr. Shin and his friend would have had to have seen ALL pages of the book and photographed them to confirm that ALL Dutch KSS Adoptees from 1964-1983 had the first digit KSS K-Number code “3”. But KSS continued to process overseas adoptions until 2012. So there would have been absolutely NO WAY to have confirmed the first digit codes of KSS’ K-Numbers from just photographing two pages containing a few Dutch KSS Adoptees’ listings in the KSS books from the mid 1970s.

Dr. Shin said:

“When we went to…where the book is kept, we couldn't touch it. Only the curator, wearing rubber gloves, was allowed to turn the pages of the book.”

“The book cannot be shared because it contains a great deal of private information, even if it is digitized.”

+

These KSS books were ultimately submitted to TRC 2. However, again, since the books only go until 1983, and KSS continued processing adoptions until 2012, there is NO WAY that ALL KSS first digit K-Number codes could have been solved from just these KSS books alone. Even with TRC 2 investigator’s full access to the KSS books, there would be no way to discover from them what I had discovered from research through the KSS Adoptee community directly between 2020-2021.

+

The issue of Adoptees’ privacy is part of why I have not published the list of hundreds of KSS Adoptees’ K-Numbers which I collected between 2020-2021 as part of my original KSS K-Number research, in which ALL first digit K-Number codes were decoded. However, I have shared my redacted data with the KSS Adoptee community privately, and have used the data for years to try to connect Adoptees to one another.

I also possess footage from my 2021 meeting at KSS and with an Associated Press (AP) reporter, where I share my research.

The egregious plagiarism attempt against my KSS K-Number research on January 1st, 2023 by DKRG and this DoKAD is WHY KSS’ Death Books are likely now PERMANENTLY LOST.

+

Below:

The KSS books:
1964-1975
1976-*1983

KSS processed overseas adoption between 1964-2012.

Therefore, there is likely a MISSING THIRD KSS book from 1984-2012.

Below:
"海外人鼗兒童名單I"
"List of Overseas Children I"

Below:

"海外人養兒童名單II"
List of Overseas Children II
1976-*1983

*KSS did not close until 2012.

Below:
"大韓國社會奉仕會" 
"社會愛上 法人"
(Roughly: KSS)

+

Timeline of Events:

2020-2021:
I conducted my
KSS K-Number research and solved all first digit KSS K-Number codes.

Summer 2021:
During a filmed meeting at KSS in Seoul in which an Associated Press (AP) reporter was in attendance, I used what I knew about KSS K-Number codes to try to locate my real file at KSS.

February 2022:
I had a Zoom with Dr. Shin’s friend, who is the DoKAD / son of two Dutch KSS Adoptees who had both previously witnessed my conducting my KSS K-Number research on a forum of which the three of us (not their son) were all members. During this Zoom I unfortunately confided in this DoKAD about my KSS K-Number research, and told him KSS’ first digit K-Number codes. This was understood to have been shared in confidence, but the DoKAD later informed DKRG’s Peter Moller about my research.


Fall / Winter 2022:
Dr. Shin’s DoKAD friend finds the KSS books in an archive, and claims that he has found his own evidence of KSS K-Number encoding. He does not inform me of this finding, but he informs others, from whom I learn of the discovery. I then approach Dr. Shin, who gives me additional information about the finding of these books. As I detail above, there is NO WAY that ALL of KSS’ K-Numbers could have been decoded from the very limited access which Dr. Shin and his DoKAD friend had to these KSS books, which only go up to 1983. KSS did not stop processing overseas adoption until 2012.

December 24th, 2023:
SBS released a documentary about my case, “Rebecca In Wonderland”, which features film footage from my
2021 meeting at KSS, in which I ask KSS’ then Director to search for specific files in KSS’ file room, based on my KSS K-Number decoding. KSS’ Director confirms to me on camera the first digit codes I had already solved, and also confirms my finding that KSS K-Numbers REPEATED in the 1970s.

January 1st, 2023:
Peter Moller of DKRG gave the DoKAD false credit for my KSS K-Number research, on a DKRG / TRC 2 related forum from which I was blocked. This whole fiasco is the reason for:


Why Decades Of KSS Death Records May Be Permanently Lost.

February 18th, 2024:
The DoKAD finally admitted — after over one year — that he had NO role in my KSS K-Number research, and thus NO role in decoding KSS K-Numbers.

October 2026:
An affiliate of the DoKAD uses an email address which directly references the decoding of KSS K-Numbers, intimating an ongoing second attempt at plagiarism of my KSS K-Number research — long after I thought that this matter had been permanently settled.

+

Please see related:

When I met with the TRC 3, there was a gasp in the room as they realized that KSS’ DEATH BOOKS have likely been LOST due to my being pushed out of TRC 2 by DKRG and its DoKAD affiliate. 

THE MISSING CHILDREN OF KSS.

Previous
Previous

Breaking the Silence: The Truth Behind South Korea’s Adoption Reckoning.

Next
Next

KSS’ new History page is light on facts.